housing

In 2017, $20,000 Could Buy a Home in 181 Metros. Today, Nine.

Key Takeaways

Affordability has narrowed to a handful of markets. A median-income household with $20,000 to close could buy the typical home in 181 metro areas in 2017; today it can in nine.
Seller credits barely help. Contributions up to the usable limit lift the count only to 194 in 2017 and 11 today.
2022 was the turning point. Prices had already climbed, and rising mortgage rates then pushed monthly payments beyond what incomes could support.
Credits fix cash, not payments. Seller assistance can close a cash-to-close gap but not a monthly-payment gap, which is why 311 of 378 metros now fail the payment test at every tier.

In 2017, a median-income household with only $20,000 in total cash available at closing could buy the typical home in 181 metro areas. Today, it can do so in nine.

Even if the seller is willing to contribute up to the full usable limit, the number rises to only 11.

I looked at 378 metro areas using two tests:

The buyer brings no more than $20,000 in total cash to closing—not a $20,000 down payment.
The monthly housing payment cannot exceed 28% of gross income.

Buyer cash must cover the down payment, closing costs and prepaids. Seller credits can offset eligible costs, up to the applicable conventional limit.

What the tests show

In January 2017, 181 metros passed both tests without seller assistance. Allowing seller credits up to the full usable limit increased the count to 194.

By August 2026, those numbers had fallen to nine and 11.

Metros where a median-income household with $20,000 to close can buy the typical home

Scenario	January 2017	August 2026
No seller assistance	181	9
Seller credits to full usable limit	194	11

The 2022 break

The break came in 2022. Home prices had already risen sharply. Then mortgage rates increased, pushing monthly payments beyond what household incomes could support. Seller credits can solve a cash-to-close problem. They cannot solve the monthly-payment problem.

Today, 311 of the 378 metros fail the monthly-payment test at every down-payment tier modeled. Another 56 pass the payment test but require more seller assistance than the applicable limit permits.

For most markets, this means only higher-income households with more cash on hand can transact. For a median-income household with only $20,000 available at closing, the price has to come down by a lot.

A Median-Income Household Would Need About $159,000 In Cash to Afford the Typical U.S. Home

The down payment is only part of the cash hurdle. Even after putting enough down to make the monthly payment affordable, a buyer must still cover closing costs and prepaids. Key Takeaways * The down payment is the first hurdle. A median-income household needs about $159,000 in cash to

Retail Sales Firmed in August. The Signal Is Breadth, Not the Bounce.

Retail sales rebounded sharply in August, but the headline overstates the improvement. A meaningful part of the gain reversed July's decline, gasoline prices padded the top line, and the 6.0% year-over-year increase falls to just 2.6% after a rough adjustment for inflation. Still, the

July-August 2026 Housing Market Report: Luxury Buyers Stay Active. The Rest of the Housing Market Is Under Stress.

Mortgage rates are back near 7%, buyers are pulling back and inventory is rebuilding. But the top of the market has been moving in the other direction. Key Takeaways * The story of the summer is the resilience of the luxury segment. Over the three months ending in July, our model-

Markets Expect a Hike. The Fed Should Hold.

Key Takeaways * August’s inflation acceleration was concentrated in energy, reflecting an oil-supply shock rather than an overheating U.S. economy. The relevant question is whether higher energy costs are spreading into underlying inflation. * The literature does not say central banks should ignore supply shocks. It says the appropriate